Atlanta United
Austin FC
Montreal Impact
Charlotte FC
Chicago Fire
Colorado Rapids
Columbus Crew
DC United
FC Dallas
FC Cincinnati
Houston Dynamo
Inter Miami
Los Angeles FC
LA Galaxy
Minnesota United
Nashville
New England Revolution
New York City
New York Red Bulls
Orlando City
Philadelphia Union
Portland Timbers
Real Salt Lake
San Jose Earthquakes
Seattle Sounders
Sporting Kansas
St Louis City
Toronto FC
Vancouver Whitecaps
New York City
Major League Soccer
May 17, 2025 at 9.30pm UK
Citi Field
New York Red Bulls

NY City
2 - 0
NY Red Bulls

Martinez (13'), Moralez (50')
Fernandez (30')
FT(HT: 1-0)

Eile (42'), Nealis (54'), Duncan (62')

The Match

Preview

Sports Mole previews Saturday's Major League Soccer clash between New York City FC and New York Red Bulls, including predictions, team news and possible lineups.

Form, Standings, Stats

Data Analysis

Our analysis of all available data, including recent performances and player stats up until an hour before kickoff, suggested the most likely outcome of this match was a New York City FC win with a probability of 48.93%. A win for New York Red Bulls had a probability of 27.57% and a draw had a probability of 23.5%.

The most likely scoreline for a New York City FC win was 2-1 with a probability of 9.51%. The next most likely scorelines for that outcome were 1-0 (8.66%) and 2-0 (7.57%). The likeliest New York Red Bulls win was 1-2 (6.84%), while for a drawn scoreline it was 1-1 (10.88%). The actual scoreline of 2-0 was predicted with a 7.6% likelihood. Our team at Sports Mole correctly predicted a 2-0 win for New York City FC in this match and our data analysis correctly predicted the win for New York City FC.

Result
New York City FCDrawNew York Red Bulls
48.93% (-0.535 -0.54)23.5% (0.22 0.22)27.57% (0.314 0.31)
Both teams to score 59.09% (-0.504 -0.5)
Goals
Over 2.5Under 2.5
57.8% (-0.783 -0.78)42.2% (0.78100000000001 0.78)
Over 3.5Under 3.5
35.39% (-0.788 -0.79)64.6% (0.788 0.79)
New York City FC Goals
Over 0.5Under 0.5
82.58% (-0.498 -0.5)17.41% (0.496 0.5)
Over 1.5Under 1.5
52.15% (-0.876 -0.88)47.85% (0.874 0.87)
New York Red Bulls Goals
Over 0.5Under 0.5
71.55% (-0.179 -0.18)28.44% (0.175 0.18)
Over 1.5Under 1.5
35.79% (-0.225 -0.23)64.2% (0.22299999999999 0.22)
Score Analysis
    New York City FC 48.93%
    New York Red Bulls 27.57%
    Draw 23.49%
New York City FCDrawNew York Red Bulls
2-1 @ 9.51% (-0.024000000000001 -0.02)
1-0 @ 8.66% (0.161 0.16)
2-0 @ 7.57% (0.018 0.02)
3-1 @ 5.54% (-0.106 -0.11)
3-0 @ 4.41% (-0.063 -0.06)
3-2 @ 3.48% (-0.085 -0.09)
4-1 @ 2.42% (-0.087 -0.09)
4-0 @ 1.93% (-0.06 -0.06)
4-2 @ 1.52% (-0.062 -0.06)
Other @ 3.89%
Total : 48.93%
1-1 @ 10.88% (0.15 0.15)
2-2 @ 5.98% (-0.045999999999999 -0.05)
0-0 @ 4.95% (0.171 0.17)
3-3 @ 1.46% (-0.043 -0.04)
Other @ 0.22%
Total : 23.49%
1-2 @ 6.84% (0.06 0.06)
0-1 @ 6.23% (0.185 0.19)
0-2 @ 3.91% (0.097 0.1)
1-3 @ 2.87% (0.011 0.01)
2-3 @ 2.51% (-0.032 -0.03)
0-3 @ 1.64% (0.033 0.03)
1-4 @ 0.9% (-0.001 -0)
Other @ 2.67%
Total : 27.57%

How you voted: NY City vs NY Red Bulls

New York City FC
70.0%
Draw
10.0%
New York Red Bulls
20.0%
10
Head to Head
Nov 23, 2024 10.30pm
MLS Cup Conference Semi-Finals
NY City
0-2
NY Red Bulls

Sands (34'), O'Toole (39')
Carballo (16'), Vanzeir (25')
Edelman (28')
Sep 29, 2024 12.30am
NY Red Bulls
1-5
NY City
Vanzeir (28')
Reyes (14'), Schwarz (15'), Stroud (90+5')
Moralez (5'), Martinez (7', 45+5'), Perea (30'), Gray (67')
May 19, 2024 12.30am
NY City
2-1
NY Red Bulls
Wolf (3'), Bakrar (64')
Sands (32')
Harper (45+1')
Harper (25'), Amaya (66'), Nealis (67'), Tolkin (90'), Schwarz (90+2')
Nealis (90+3')
Sep 16, 2023 8.30pm
NY City
0-0
NY Red Bulls
Pellegrini (42'), Morales (63'), Sands (90+3')
Barlow (48'), Ndam (69'), Harper (90+7'), Tolkin (90+7')
May 14, 2023 12.30am
NY Red Bulls
1-0
NY City
Fernandez (76')
Reyes (67'), Nealis (72'), Tolkin (81'), Casseres Jr (88')

Parks (37')
rhs 2.0


Sports Mole provides in-depth previews and predictions for every match from the biggest leagues and competitions in world football.
Argentina's Lionel Messi kisses the World Cup trophy after collecting the Golden Ball award on December 18, 2022Sign up for our FREE daily preview newsletter direct to your inbox!