| | First Half starts. |
| 4' | | Brenner - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick on the left wing. |
| 4' | | Fouled by Sean Nealis - New York Red Bulls |
| 4' | | Offside - FC Cincinnati. Luciano Acosta with a pass, however Brandon Vázquez is in offside. |
| 11' | | New attacking attempt. Cristian Cásseres Jr - New York Red Bulls - shot with left foot from outside the box is saved in the right corner. |
| 12' | | Missed chance. Cameron Harper - New York Red Bulls - shot with right foot from the right side of the box is close, but missed to the left. Assist - Patryk Klimala with a head. |
| 13' | | Brandon Vázquez - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in attack. |
| 13' | | Fouled by Andrés Reyes - New York Red Bulls |
| 14' | | Goal! New York Red Bulls 0, FC Cincinnati 1. Matt Miazga - FC Cincinnati - shot with the head from the centre of the box to the right corner. Assist - Álvaro Barreal . |
| 16' | | Cameron Harper - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick on the right wing. |
| 16' | | Fouled by Luciano Acosta - FC Cincinnati |
| 17' | | Shot blocked. Patryk Klimala - New York Red Bulls - shot with right foot from the centre of the box is blocked. Assist - John Tolkin with a cross. |
| 18' | | Fouled by Cameron Harper - New York Red Bulls |
| 18' | | Matt Miazga - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. |
| 19' | | Penalty New York Red Bulls. Andrés Reyes draws a foul in the penalty area. |
| 19' | | Penalty conceded by Júnior Moreno - FC Cincinnati - after a foul in the penalty area. |
| 21' | | VAR Decision: Penalty New York Red Bulls. |
| 23' | | Goal! New York Red Bulls 1, FC Cincinnati 1. Patryk Klimala - New York Red Bulls - converts the penalty with a shot with right foot to the centre of the goal. |
| 24' | | Hand ball by Sean Nealis - New York Red Bulls |
| 30' | | Brenner - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick on the left wing. |
| 30' | | Fouled by Patryk Klimala - New York Red Bulls |
| 31' | | Offside - FC Cincinnati. Nick Hagglund with a pass, however Brandon Vázquez is in offside. |
| 32' | | Corner - New York Red Bulls. Conceded by Matt Miazga. |
| 36' | | Alvas Powell - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. |
| 36' | | Fouled by John Tolkin - New York Red Bulls |
| 37' | | Fouled by Matt Miazga - FC Cincinnati |
| 37' | | Patryk Klimala - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in attack. |
| 37' | | Matt Miazga - FC Cincinnati - receive yellow card for a foul. |
| 39' | | Shot blocked. Cristian Cásseres Jr - New York Red Bulls - shot with right foot from outside the box is blocked. |
| 39' | | Cameron Harper - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick on the right wing. |
| 39' | | Fouled by Álvaro Barreal - FC Cincinnati |
| 41' | | Shot blocked. Daniel Edelman - New York Red Bulls - shot with left foot from outside the box is blocked. Assist - Cameron Harper. |
| 42' | | Fouled by Brandon Vázquez - FC Cincinnati |
| 42' | | John Tolkin - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in defence. |
| 43' | | Fouled by Caden Clark - New York Red Bulls |
| 43' | | Obinna Nwobodo - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. |
| 45+1' | | Fouled by Cristian Cásseres Jr - New York Red Bulls |
| 45+1' | | Matt Miazga - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. |
| 45+4' | | First Half ended - New York Red Bulls 1, FC Cincinnati 1. |
| 45' | | Second Half starts New York Red Bulls 1, FC Cincinnati 1. |
| 48' | | Shot blocked. John Tolkin - New York Red Bulls - shot with right foot from outside the box is blocked. |
| 48' | | Corner - New York Red Bulls. Conceded by Geoff Cameron. |
| 49' | | Missed chance. Andrés Reyes - New York Red Bulls - shot with the head from a diffucult position on the left missed to the left. Assist - John Tolkin with a cross after corner. |
| 50' | | Shot blocked. Álvaro Barreal - FC Cincinnati - shot with left foot from the centre of the box is blocked. Assist - Brenner. |
| 50' | | Corner - FC Cincinnati. Conceded by Sean Nealis. |
| 53' | | Alvas Powell - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick on the right wing. |
| 53' | | Fouled by John Tolkin - New York Red Bulls |
| 53' | | New attacking attempt. Cameron Harper - New York Red Bulls - shot with left foot from the right side of the box is saved in the top right corner. Assist - Dru Yearwood. |
| 58' | | Substitution - New York Red Bulls. Lewis Morgan for Caden Clark. |
| 58' | | Substitution - New York Red Bulls. Aaron Long for Andrés Reyes. |
| 58' | | Substitution - New York Red Bulls. Luquinhas for Cameron Harper. |
| 61' | | Shot blocked. Lewis Morgan - New York Red Bulls - shot with the head from the centre of the box is blocked. |
| 62' | | Substitution - FC Cincinnati. Ian Murphy for Matt Miazga. |
| 64' | | Fouled by Kyle Duncan - New York Red Bulls |
| 64' | | Álvaro Barreal - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. |
| 66' | | Cristian Cásseres Jr - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in attack. |
| 66' | | Fouled by Obinna Nwobodo - FC Cincinnati |
| 66' | | Obinna Nwobodo - FC Cincinnati - receive yellow card for a foul. |
| 67' | | Missed chance. Lewis Morgan - New York Red Bulls - shot with left foot from outside the box is high and wide to the right from a free kick. |
| 69' | | Fouled by Brandon Vázquez - FC Cincinnati |
| 69' | | John Tolkin - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in defence. |
| 71' | | Shot blocked. Patryk Klimala - New York Red Bulls - shot with right foot from the right side of the box is blocked. Assist - Luquinhas. |
| 73' | | Corner - New York Red Bulls. Conceded by Álvaro Barreal. |
| 74' | | Missed chance. Daniel Edelman - New York Red Bulls - shot with right foot from the centre of the box goes high. |
| 75' | | Substitution - New York Red Bulls. Steven Sserwadda for Dru Yearwood. |
| 75' | | Shot blocked. Luquinhas - New York Red Bulls - shot with right foot from the right side of the box is blocked. Assist - Patryk Klimala. |
| 75' | | Fouled by Daniel Edelman - New York Red Bulls |
| 75' | | Álvaro Barreal - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. |
| 76' | | Daniel Edelman - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in defence. |
| 76' | | Fouled by Júnior Moreno - FC Cincinnati |
| 77' | | Fouled by Kyle Duncan - New York Red Bulls |
| 77' | | Álvaro Barreal - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. |
| 77' | | Substitution - FC Cincinnati. Raymon Gaddis for Alvas Powell. |
| 78' | | Substitution - FC Cincinnati. Yuya Kubo for Júnior Moreno. |
| 78' | | Substitution - FC Cincinnati. John Nelson for Álvaro Barreal. |
| 78' | | Brandon Vázquez - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick on the left wing. |
| 78' | | Fouled by Kyle Duncan - New York Red Bulls |
| 81' | | Kyle Duncan - New York Red Bulls |
| 81' | | Yuya Kubo - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. |
| 81' | | Fouled by Brandon Vázquez - FC Cincinnati |
| 81' | | Sean Nealis - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in defence. |
| 83' | | Cristian Cásseres Jr - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick on the left wing. |
| 83' | | Fouled by Yuya Kubo - FC Cincinnati |
| 83' | | Substitution - New York Red Bulls. Tom Barlow for Patryk Klimala. |
| 85' | | Fouled by Daniel Edelman - New York Red Bulls |
| 85' | | Obinna Nwobodo - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. |
| 85' | | Daniel Edelman - New York Red Bulls - receive yellow card for a foul. |
| 87' | | New attacking attempt. Brenner - FC Cincinnati - shot with left foot from outside the box is saved by goalkeeper in the centre of the goal. Assist - Luciano Acosta. |
| 88' | | Fouled by Brandon Vázquez - FC Cincinnati |
| 88' | | John Tolkin - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in defence. |
| 90' | | Substitution - FC Cincinnati. Arquimides Ordóñez for Brandon Vázquez. |