US Open Cup
Columbus Crew
May 21, 2026 12.30am
1
0
HT : 0 0
FT Historic Crew Stadium
NY City
  • Max Arfsten 59' goal
  • Yevgen Cheberko 64' yellowcard
  • Hugo Picard 64' yellowcard
  • 64' yellowcard
  • Mohamed Farsi 75' yellowcard
  • Dylan Chambost 76' yellowcard
  • Jamal Thiaré 76' yellowcard
  • Jamal Thiaré 77' yellowcard
  • yellowcard Malachi Jones 64'
  • yellowcard 64'
  • yellowcard Arnau Farnós 64'
  • yellowcard Máximo Carrizo 64'
  • yellowcard Seymour Reid 64'
  • yellowcard Seymour Reid 65'
  • yellowcard Strahinja Tanasijević 87'

Columbus Crew vs New York City FC - Match Guide, Data Analysis, Standings

Form, Standings, Stats

Columbus Crew

All competitions

New York City FC

All competitions

Data analysis

Our analysis of all available data, including recent performances and player stats up until an hour before kickoff, suggested the most likely outcome of this match was a Columbus Crew win with a probability of 58.33%. A win for New York City FC had a probability of 20.86% and a draw had a probability of 20.81%.

The most likely scoreline for a Columbus Crew win was 2-1 with a probability of 9.95%. The next most likely scorelines for that outcome were 1-0 (9.15%) and 2-0 (8.66%). The likeliest New York City FC win was 1-2 (5.68%) , while for a drawn scoreline it was 1-1 (9.37%). The actual scoreline of 1-0 was predicted with a 9.2% likelihood.

Result

Columbus Crew 58.33%
Draw 20.81%
New York City FC 20.86%

Both Teams to Score: 

57.91%

Goals

Over 1.5 81.7%
Under 1.5 18.3%
Over 2.5 61.02%
Under 2.5 38.98%
Over 3.5 38.2%
Under 3.5 61.8%
Over 4.5 24.31%
Under 4.5 75.69%

First Half Winner

Columbus Crew 46.37%
Draw 34.64% ▼ (-0.01)
New York City FC 18.99%

Team To Score First

Columbus Crew 64.82% ▲ (+0.02)
No Goal 4.33%
New York City FC 30.85% ▼ (-0.02)

Corners

Over 8 49.23%
Equal 8 11.86%
Under 8 38.91%
Over 9 37.93%
Equal 9 11.3%
Under 9 50.77%
Over 10.5 28%
Under 10.5 72%

Columbus Crew Goals

Over 1.5 58.19% ▼ (-0.02)
Under 1.5 41.81% ▲ (+0.02)
Over 2.5 32.03%
Under 2.5 67.97%
Over 3.5 14.48%
Under 3.5 85.52%

New York City FC Goals

Over 0.5 57.47%
Under 0.5 42.53%
Over 1.5 27.09%
Under 1.5 72.91%
Over 2.5 9.18%
Under 2.5 90.82%
Over 3.5 2.76%
Under 3.5 97.24%

Score analysis

Columbus Crew 58.32%
Draw 20.81%
New York City FC 20.86%
Columbus Crew
2-1 @ 9.95% ▼ (-0.02)
1-0 @ 9.15% ▼ (-0.01)
2-0 @ 8.66%
3-1 @ 6.25%
3-0 @ 6.02%
3-2 @ 3.93%
Other @ 14.36%
Total : 58.32%
Draw
1-1 @ 9.37% ▲ (+0.01)
2-2 @ 5.64%
0-0 @ 4.33%
3-3 @ 1.35%
Other @ 0.12%
Total : 20.81%
New York City FC
1-2 @ 5.68%
0-1 @ 4.81%
0-2 @ 2.66%
1-3 @ 2%
2-3 @ 1.91%
0-3 @ 1.16%
Other @ 2.64%
Total : 20.86%

Head to Head

Major League Soccer
NY City
May 10, 2026 9.30pm
3
0
HT : 2 0
FT Yankee Stadium
Columbus Crew
  • Hannes Wolf 12' goal
  • Hannes Wolf 16' goal
  • Hannes Wolf 66' goal
  • Malachi Jones 85' yellowcard
  • Jonathan Shore 85' yellowcard
  • Arnau Farnós 88' yellowcard
  • Máximo Carrizo 90'+1' yellowcard
  • Seymour Reid 90'+2' yellowcard
  • yellowcard Sekou Tidiany Bangoura 68'
  • yellowcard Mohamed Farsi 68'
  • yellowcard Dániel Gazdag 68'
  • yellowcard Amar Sejdić 79'
  • yellowcard Nariman Akhundzada 79'
  • yellowcard Nariman Akhundzada 80'
Major League Soccer MLS Playoffs
NY City
Sep 18, 2025 12.30am
3
2
HT : 0 0
FT
Columbus Crew
Major League Soccer
Columbus Crew
Mar 22, 2025 11.30pm
0
0
HT : 0 0
FT Lower.com Field
NY City
  • Jacen Russell-Rowe 84' goal
Major League Soccer
Columbus Crew
Sep 1, 2024 12.30am
4
2
HT : 2 2
FT Lower.com Field
NY City
  • Diego Rossi 17' goal
  • Diego Rossi 17' goal
  • Malte Amundsen 21' yellowcard
  • Malte Amundsen 21' yellowcard
  • Max Arfsten 59' goal
  • Max Arfsten 59' goal
  • DeJuan Jones 90'+3' goal
  • DeJuan Jones 90'+3' goal
  • Jacen Russell-Rowe 90'+10' goal
  • Jacen Russell-Rowe 90'+10' goal
  • goal Alonso Martinez 4'
  • goal Alonso Martinez 4'
  • yellowcard Maximiliano Moralez 72'
  • yellowcard Maximiliano Moralez 72'
  • yellowcard Santiago Rodriguez 85'
  • yellowcard Santiago Rodriguez 85'
  • goal Monsef Bakrar 86'
  • goal Monsef Bakrar 86'
  • redcard Julian Fernandez 90'+5'
  • redcard Julian Fernandez 90'+5'
Leagues Cup
Columbus Crew
Aug 17, 2024 11.00pm
1
1
HT : 1 1
FT MAPFRE Stadium
NY City
  • Juan Camilo Hernandez 41' goal
  • goal Alonso Martinez 1'
  • yellowcard Christian McFarlane 26'
  • yellowcard Santiago Rodriguez 88'
Major League Soccer
NY City
Jun 15, 2024 1.40am
2
3
HT : 2 0
FT Yankee Stadium
Columbus Crew
  • Strahinja Tanasijevic 33' yellowcard
  • Strahinja Tanasijevic 33' yellowcard
  • Mitja Ilencic 39' redcard
  • Mitja Ilencic 39' redcard
  • Agustin Ojeda 44' goal
  • Agustin Ojeda 44' goal
  • Santiago Rodriguez 86' goal
  • Santiago Rodriguez 86' goal
  • Maximiliano Moralez 90'+9' yellowcard
  • Maximiliano Moralez 90'+9' yellowcard
  • Keaton Parks 90'+10' yellowcard
  • Keaton Parks 90'+15' yellowcard
  • Santiago Rodriguez 90'+15' yellowcard
  • Santiago Rodriguez 90'+15' yellowcard
  • goal Christian Ramirez 51'
  • goal Christian Ramirez 51'
  • goal Mohamed Farsi 53'
  • goal Mohamed Farsi 53'
  • yellowcard Yevgen Cheberko 58'
  • yellowcard Yevgen Cheberko 58'
  • goal Juan Camilo Hernandez 63'
  • goal Juan Camilo Hernandez 63'
  • yellowcard Diego Rossi 90'+1'
  • yellowcard Diego Rossi 90'+1'

Form Data

Philadelphia 1 - 1 Columbus Crew
NY Red Bulls 2 - 2 Columbus Crew
NY City 3 - 0 Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew 2 - 3 Minnesota Utd
Columbus Crew 4 - 1 One Knoxville
Columbus Crew 2 - 0 Philadelphia
NY Red Bulls 1 - 1 NY City
Charlotte FC 0 - 1 NY City
NY City 3 - 0 Columbus Crew
NY City 0 - 2 DC United
NY Red Bulls 1 - 3 NY City
Montreal 1 - 0 NY City