Premier League
Dec 20, 2025 12.30pm
2
2
HT : 2 0
FT
  • Nick Woltemade 4' goal
  • Nick Woltemade 20' goal
  • Fabian Schar 61' yellowcard
  • Yoane Wissa 77' yellowcard
  • Lewis Hall 86' yellowcard
  • Lewis Hall 87' yellowcard
  • yellowcard Robert Sanchez 7'
  • yellowcard Robert Sanchez 8'
  • yellowcard Alejandro Garnacho 27'
  • yellowcard Malo Gusto 45'
  • yellowcard Enzo Maresca 45'
  • goal Reece James 49'
  • yellowcard Enzo Maresca 59'
  • goal Joao Pedro 66'
  • yellowcard Moises Caicedo 70'
  • yellowcard Andrey Santos 82'
  • yellowcard Joao Pedro 83'

Newcastle 2-2 Chelsea: PGMOL explain Anthony Gordon, Trevoh Chalobah penalty decision as Nick Woltemade joins exclusive club

PGMOL explain Gordon-Chalobah penalty decision in chaotic Newcastle-Chelsea draw

The Premier League Match Centre have explained why Newcastle United were not awarded a penalty in their chaotic 2-2 draw with Chelsea at St James' Park on Saturday lunchtime.

The Magpies painfully threw away a two-goal lead to claim just one point against the Club World Cup winners, who were second best in the first half and deservedly went into the break 2-0 down thanks to a Nick Woltemade double.

The Blues quickly hit back a few minutes after the restart through a Reece James free kick, though, before Joao Pedro completed the Chelsea turnaround midway through the second period.

In between both of the visitors' goals, though, Newcastle fans were incensed at the decision not to award their side a penalty when Trevoh Chalobah barged into Anthony Gordon inside the penalty area.

Gordon was chasing to keep the ball in play before being clattered into by Chalobah, who seemingly made no attempt to play the ball, but on-field referee Andy Madley and VAR official Peter Bankes saw nothing wrong with the challenge.

Newcastle 2-2 Chelsea: Eddie Howe reacts to penalty call after PGMOL explanation

Posting on X - formerly known as Twitter - the PL Match Centre revealed that the officials deemed the incident a "shielding action" with Chalobah "side-by-side" with Gordon.

"The referee’s call of no penalty to Newcastle was checked and confirmed by VAR – with the contact from Chalobah on Gordon deemed to be side-to-side in a shielding action and the ball within playing distance," the post read.

Newcastle boss Eddie Howe unsurprisingly took a different view of the incident, when he was asked by TNT Sports whether he understood the "shielding action" explanation given to justify not awarding the spot kick.

"No, because it's not," the Englishman said. "The defender's only looking at Anthony, not the ball, and I think it's too aggressive."

Madley also enraged the Newcastle fans right before the final whistle, when Harvey Barnes raced through only to go down under pressure from James, but the Chelsea captain escaped a red card for possible denial of a goalscoring opportunity.

Newcastle 2-2 Chelsea: Nick Woltemade emulates Sergio Aguero and Manchester United legend

Before things went pear-shaped for the EFL Cup holders on home soil, Woltemade - who lost the Tyne-Wear derby for Newcastle last weekend with his own goal against Sunderland - got back in the St James' Park good books.

The Germany international crashed home the opening goal after Robert Sanchez had denied Anthony Gordon, before just about staying onside and poking home a second for the hosts midway through the first half.

In doing so, Woltemade became just the fourth man to score twice in the opening 20 minutes of a Premier League game against Chelsea, joining extremely elite company in Robbie Fowler, Paul Scholes and Sergio Aguero.

Fowler was the first to do so for Liverpool in 1994, before Scholes achieved the feat for Manchester United in 1995 and Aguero for Manchester City in 2019.

Newcastle's point temporarily takes them above Tottenham Hotspur into 11th place in the Premier League table, while Chelsea remain fourth, four points behind third-placed Aston Villa.

Share this article:
Subscribe to our newsletter

Get FREE daily news and in-depth previews for games from the biggest leagues and competitions in world football — straight to your inbox.

Subscribe