Four minutes later they extended their advantage with a try from Kane Linnett, with Brough kicking over again.
© Getty Images
They closed the gap to within two points thanks to a try from Raymond Nasso with Mantellato converting.
Danny Addy went over to extend the Scot's lead going into half time, with Brough kicking over.
After the break, Nasso went over and Mantellato converted, before Brett Hellewell scored Scotland's fourth try of the game and Brough kicked over.
With 10 minutes to go, Scotland levelled the scores with their fifth try of the match through Hellewell, but Brough was unable to convert and the game finished in a draw.