MX23RW : Wednesday, April 24 23:14:47| >> :600:94978566:94978566:

Bury phoenix club chief: 'No appetite for reform among football authorities'

The idea of a fan ownership model has gained traction following supporter protests about the European Super League.

Football authorities in England do not have the appetite for the sort of meaningful change that would give power to supporters, according to the chief at Bury's fan-owned phoenix club.

Phil Young is the chairman of the Shakers Community, which owns non-league Bury AFC – the club which was formed after League One side Bury FC were kicked out of the English Football League following financial troubles.

He believes a fan ownership model could work higher up the football pyramid – but does not believe the will is there among the sport's governing bodies to make it happen.

Bury fans react to bad news
Bury fans were left despondent when their club was kicked out of League One (Peter Byrne/PA)

"It's a hard one to resolve without a significant amount of pain to change the structure of ownership in English football," Young told the PA news agency.

"And I'm not sure that it's something any of the organisations that have been complaining – the likes of Premier League and the FA – I'm not sure any of them have got the appetite to do the hard work that's required to fundamentally reform and restructure the game."

Bury were expelled from the EFL in 2019 after financial mismanagement left them unable to fulfil their fixtures, a situation which a Digital Culture Media and Sport committee found the EFL contributed to by failing to intervene.

And it is that unwillingness to get involved in clubs' business which Young feels would have to shift if there were to be any serious changes to how football is run.

"The EFL would have to have powers way beyond what they've got at the moment and be far more interventionist and far more hands-on involved potentially in the running of some of these football clubs if it went wrong," he said.

"And I just don't think any of these organisations have the appetite to be anything other than a very loose kind of affiliation group."

As with recent wranglings among the Premier League's so-called big six clubs over a potential European super league, Young said it shows clubs and fans are "completely at the whim and mercy of individuals".

Phil Young
Phil Young does not believe football's authorities have the appetite that would be needed for widespread fan ownership (Shakers Community)

The idea of fan ownership has become a live topic after supporters revolted over plans by Manchester City, Manchester United, Liverpool, Chelsea, Arsenal and Tottenham to join the proposed new competition.

It was a situation that led to Prime Minister Boris Johnson suggesting he was prepared to drop a "legislative bomb" on the sport – giving hope that some form of fan ownership could be facilitated.

Bury AFC, who are in the 10th tier of English football, are owned entirely by the Shakers Community, which is financed by its more than 1,500 members.

Members vote on many issues from ticketing policies to kit design, while footballing decisions – such as picking the team's manager – are left to the board and club officials.

League Two side Exeter also have a fan ownership model, with the Exeter City Supporters' Trust owning a majority shareholding.

Members elect trustees, who sit on the club's board and have a "very significant say in how the club is run", according to trust chairman Nick Hawker.

Exeter City's stadium
Exeter are majority owned by a supporters' trust (Simon Galloway/PA)

"We're still competing with all the other clubs who aren't supporter owned and so we feel that the way we run the business makes up for the lack of funding that perhaps you might get from a wealthy owner," Hawker said.

Supporters of Newcastle recently launched an attempt to raise enough money to buy a stake in their club, whose owner Mike Ashley is largely unpopular with fans.

And Hawker believes the model could work in the Premier League – but significant rule changes would be needed if they were ever to compete with clubs funded in other ways.

"We have no beef about big clubs being big clubs and competing at a higher level than us," he said.

"Our beef is when big clubs go into huge debt in order to compete and are gifted money by wealthy owners or the clubs are compromised in terms of loans in order to gain success.

"I see no reason why the model wouldn't work at a Premier League club, and especially clubs like Newcastle who I always sense are a big part of the community there, but I think there has to be equalisation of how clubs are funded.

"Fine if they're funded through their own operational means but if people are throwing money and we have playing budgets and operational budgets that are far beyond what the club actually makes operationally, that's what makes it impossible."

Hawker said he felt a sense of "hopelessness" when he first saw the latest plans for a European Super League.

Nick Hawker
Nick Hawker described the proposed super league's PR as an 'absolute disaster' (Exeter City Supporters' Trust)

He described the scheme's PR as "an absolute disaster" but said the backlash was symptomatic of the fact that some big clubs have drifted away from their communities.

"It was sad that clubs didn't anticipate what was about to happen," he said. "It demonstrates that clearly they are out of touch not just with their customers but the sense that the world was against it.

"It's amazing that people at that level who have been so successful in their lives could misjudge something so massively."

ID:444198: cacheID:444198:1false2false3false:QQ:: from db desktop :LenBod:restore:10739:
Restore Data
Share this article now:
General view of Bury's Gigg Lane from 2014
Read Next:
Former Bury doctor suspended for breach of FA anti-doping regulations
>
rhs 2.0
Today's games header
10am
Blanch
Nadal
10am
Cachin
Ofner
10am
Elahi Galan
Bautista-Agut
10am
Gasquet
Sonego
10am
Hanfmann
Mensik
10am
Koepfer
Carballes Baena
10am
Kovacevic
Medjedovic
10am
Lajovic
Monteiro
10am
Machac
Ruusuvuori
10am
Michelsen
Fonseca
10am
Nishioka
Auger-Aliassime
10am
O'Connell
Arnaldi
10am
Purcell
Giron
10am
Ramos-Vinolas
Kotov
10am
Tabilo
Cobolli
10am
Zhizhen
Kecmanovic
10am
Azarenka
Maria
10am
Eala
Cirstea
10am
Annie Fernandez
Potapova
10am
Gauff
Rus
10am
Keys
Camelia-Begu
10am
Podoroska
Navarro
10am
Karolina Schmiedlova
Jabeur
10am
Swiatek
Wang
10am
Baez
Van Assche
10am
Coric
Zverev
10am
Martin Etcheverry
Shapovalov
10am
Humbert
Van De Zandschulp
10am
Hurkacz
Draper
10am
Marozsan
Cerundolo
10am
Paul
Klein
10am
Rublev
Bagnis
10am
Altmaier
Fils
10am
Darderi
Fritz
10am
Griekspoor
Daniel
10am
Munar
Struff
10am
Musetti
Seyboth Wild
10am
Navone
Rune
10am
Shevchenko
Alcaraz
10am
Alexandrova
Krueger
10am
Andreeva
Noskova
10am
Bejlek
Kalinskaya
10am
Boulter
Montgomery
10am
Bronzetti
Rybakina
10am
Collins
Danilovic
3pm
Cristian
Krejcikova
10am
Dolehide
Kalinina
10am
Garcia
Wang
10am
Linette
Sabalenka
10am
Pavlyuchenkova
Saville
10am
Sorribes Tormo
Svitolina
10am
Vekic
Sakkari
11.30am
Arango
Yastremska
11.30am
Osaka
Samsonova
11.30am
Ostapenko
Bouzas Maneiro
1pm
Haddad Maia
Errani
2.30pm
Lourdes Carle
Kudermetova
2.30pm
Mertens
Stephens
Tables header RHS
TeamPWDLFAGDPTS
1Arsenal34245582265677
2Liverpool34228475344174
3Manchester CityMan City32227376324473
4Aston Villa34206871502166
5Tottenham HotspurSpurs32186865491660
6Manchester UnitedMan Utd33165125150153
7Newcastle UnitedNewcastle331551369541550
8West Ham UnitedWest Ham34139125463-948
9Chelsea32138116157447
10Bournemouth34129134960-1145
11Brighton & Hove AlbionBrighton321111105250244
12Wolverhampton WanderersWolves34127154654-843
13Fulham34126165054-442
14Crystal Palace34109154456-1239
15Brentford3498175259-735
16Everton34118153648-1233
17Nottingham ForestNott'm Forest3479184260-1826
18Luton TownLuton3467214775-2825
19Burnley3458213769-3223
20Sheffield UnitedSheff Utd3437243392-5916


Sports Mole provides in-depth previews and predictions for every match from the biggest leagues and competitions in world football.
Argentina's Lionel Messi kisses the World Cup trophy after collecting the Golden Ball award on December 18, 2022Sign up for our FREE daily preview newsletter direct to your inbox!