Sherman entered a war of words with Revis last year over who was the better player and declared that he was the best in the game in a post-match interview.
However, McCoy does not think that is the case after watching the two closely.
"I would take Darrelle Revis, he's better," McCoy told SiriusXM. "If you watch Darrelle Revis's tape, and you take Sherman, it's not even close."
McCoy rushed for 1,607 yards in the 2013 season, scoring a total of 11 touchdowns.