MX23RW : Tuesday, March 19 11:01:18| >> :120:45637:45637:

Player Ratings: Newcastle United 1-0 Aston Villa

Sports Mole analyses the players' performances in Aston Villa's 1-0 defeat at Newcastle United.

Newcastle United edged out relegation-threatened Aston Villa with a 1-0 victory at St James' Park for what was the Magpies' first home win under John Carver.

Papiss Cisse's first-half strike proved enough to give United all three points and just their second victory in 2015.

The defeat piles more pressure on Villa, meanwhile, as Tim Sherwood's side stay 19th in the table and remain without a victory in 12 Premier League outings.

Here, Sports Mole analyses who excelled and who didn't in the North-East this afternoon.

Papiss Demba Cisse of Newcastle United celebrates scoring the opening goal during the Barclays Premier League match between Newcastle United and Aston Villa at St James' Park on February 28, 2015© Getty Images



NEWCASTLE UNITED

Goal

Tim Krul: Only had one or two difficult saves to make but managed to stay alert after long spells of inactivity by virtue of Newcastle's second-half dominance. (6/10)

Defence

Daryl Janmaat: One crucial goal-saving intervention to prevent Sinclair from tapping home a Benteke cross early on. Got forward often, too, and drilled in the ball that led to Cisse's opening goal. (7/10)

Mike Williamson: Looked very impressive alongside Coloccini and managed to keep Benteke relatively quiet throughout. Excellent performance. (7/10)

Fabricio Coloccini: His bravery played a big role in the win as he threw himself in the line of fire to block Westwood's stinging shot in the second half. Like Williamson, the Argentine was brilliant overall. (7/10)

Massadio Haidara: Got forward really well but was stretchered off on the hour mark and replaced by Ryan Taylor. Looked a serious one. (6/10)

Midfield

Mehdi Abeid: Shielded Newcastle's defence well throughout, which allowed Sissoko more freedom in advanced areas of the field. (6/10)

Gabriel Obertan: One to forget for the winger, who could, and should, have put the game to bed in the second half but some woeful decision making let him down badly. (4/10)

Moussa Sissoko: Tireless performance from the Frenchman in midfield and can take plenty of heart from the result. (6/10)

Sammy Ameobi: Never really got into the game on that left-hand flank but did get through some good defensive work. Never on the same wavelength as left-back Haidara in attack, though. (5/10)

Attack

Emmanuel Riviere: Hadn't started a Premier League in all of five months prior to this afternoon, and it showed as the Frenchman looked a little rusty and spurned a good chance to make it 2-0 before the break. (4/10)

Papiss Cisse: Brilliant all-round performance from the striker, who struck the decisive blow on 37 minutes but remained dangerous throughout. (7/10)

Substitutes

Ryan Taylor: One or two huge defensive moments to keep out Villa and looked a menace in attack, too. Good cameo. (6/10)

Yoan Gouffran: Replaced Obertan on 78 minutes but did not look any more involved than his compatriot. Not the greatest impact. (4/10)



ASTON VILLA

Goal

Brad Guzan: Could do very little about the goal and made one or two tidy saves to prevent the Magpies from extending their lead. (6/10)

Defence

Alan Hutton: Started well but dipped as the game went on and did not do anywhere near enough in the final third after the break. Still managed to keep Ameobi fairly quiet, however. (5/10)

Jores Okore: At times looked an admirable deputy in the absence of the suspended Ron Vlaar, but let himself down for Newcastle's opener by failing to clear Janmaat's cross. (5/10)

Ciaran Clark: Could have perhaps done more on the goal but looked relatively decent other than that. Booked for a cynical foul but good game overall. (6/10)

Matt Lowton: Stepped in to replace the injured Kieran Richardson at left-back and did a good job by keeping Obertan quiet throughout. (6/10)

Midfield

Tom Cleverley: Missed arguably the best chance of the game in the second half by drilling a shot straight at Krul. Little more composure and Villa might have earned a point. (4/10)

Fabian Delph: Struggled with the pace and power of Sissoko at times and struggled to contribute much in an attacking sense. (5/10)

Scott Sinclair: Scored in his first two Villa outings but a hat-trick was never on the cards today. Ineffective throughout and replaced on 66 minutes. (5/10)

Ashley Westwood: Had a few decent shots but his delivery from set pieces let him and his side down regularly throughout the 90 minutes. (5/10)

Attack

Gabriel Agbonlahor: Another Villa attacker who endured a relatively quiet afternoon. His pace caused a few problems at times but these moments were far too rare. (5/10)

Christian Benteke: His confidence was a talking point before the match but the big Belgian had the confidence to try two overheads; one of which he nearly scored from. Not at his best but does not look far off that level. (6/10)

Substitutes

Charles N'Zogbia: His introduction gave Villa a little impetus but not enough to earn a point. Missed a half-chance in the closing stages. (5/10)

Andreas Weimann: Did his bid for future starts no good at all with a relatively lifeless cameo. (4/10)


ID:208096: cacheID:208096:1false2false3false:QQ:: from db desktop :LenBod:restore:8457:No Data Analysis info
Restore Data
Share this article now:
Papiss Demba Cisse of Newcastle United celebrates scoring the opening goal during the Barclays Premier League match between Newcastle United and Aston Villa at St James' Park on February 28, 2015
Read Next:
Match Analysis: Newcastle United 1-0 Aston Villa
>
rhs 2.0
Today's games header
Tables header RHS
TeamPWDLFAGDPTS
1Arsenal28204470244664
2Liverpool28197265263964
3Manchester CityMan City28196363283563
4Aston Villa29175760421856
5Tottenham HotspurSpurs28165759421753
6Manchester UnitedMan Utd28152113939047
7West Ham UnitedWest Ham2912894650-444
8Brighton & Hove AlbionBrighton2811985044642
9Wolverhampton WanderersWolves28125114244-241
10Newcastle UnitedNewcastle281241259481140
11Chelsea27116104745239
12Fulham29115134344-138
13Bournemouth2898114152-1135
14Crystal Palace2878133348-1529
15Brentford2975174154-1326
16Everton2887132939-1025
17Luton TownLuton2957174260-1822
18Nottingham ForestNott'm Forest2967163551-1621
19Burnley2945202963-3417
20Sheffield UnitedSheff Utd2835202474-5014

Subscribe to our newsletter


Sports Mole provides in-depth previews and predictions for every match from the biggest leagues and competitions in world football.
Argentina's Lionel Messi kisses the World Cup trophy after collecting the Golden Ball award on December 18, 2022Sign up for our FREE daily preview newsletter direct to your inbox!