The Three Lions upset the World and European Championships in November 2011, when Frank Lampard scored the only goal of the game to give the home side a 1-0 win at Wembley in a friendly.
While the Brazil match is also a friendly, the Everton centre-back is adamant that there is still a lot riding on the fixture.
"This is a high-stakes game," Jagielka told ESPN.
"That Spain game wasn't make or break but because we won and kept a clean sheet it turned into a massive positive.
"It is a similar situation now. Whether I get to play, or someone else, it is about gaining experience from a great test."
England host Brazil at Wembley on Wednesday.